HMRC Penalties and Impact on Low Incomes
Over the past five years, HMRC has issued approximately 600,000 late-filing penalties to tax filers whose incomes were too low to incur any income tax. This disproportionately affects low-income and vulnerable taxpayers, in some cases more so than those in higher income brackets.
Since 2011, fixed penalties have not been capped by the tax actually owed, meaning individuals owing no tax can still face penalties up to £1,600. Planned reforms will introduce a points-based penalty regime with lower fines, but these changes, tied to the Making Tax Digital rollout, will only reach taxpayers with incomes over £20,000 by 2028. There is currently no implementation date for those earning less. Advocacy groups have described this as an unfair “two-tier system”.
Policy experts estimate that abolishing penalties for low-income non-payers would cost the Treasury approximately £6 million annually a comparatively low figure for a measure with broad social benefits. The Budget may address calls for more equitable treatment.